Jessica Simpson Thinks She is Having a Girl!

We all know Jessica Simpson is pregnant but what we don’t know is the gender of her baby…buts she thinks she is having a girl, but fiance Eric Johnson things they are having a boy! Hmmm, Which is it?

Jessica Simpson and fiancé Eric Johnson are pretty sure they know what to expect when they’re expecting – if only they could agree.

“I think it’s a girl,” Simpson, 31, told PEOPLE at the New York launch of a clothing line that she and sister Ashlee Simpson created. “But I don’t know yet.”

“I think it’s a boy,” says Johnson, who was on hand at Dylan’s Candy Bar in New York along with future mother-in-law Tina Simpson. “We’re pretty much at a standstill there.”

But the couple plans to find out their baby’s gender.

“If it’s a boy,” she quips, “I’ll put him in tutus!”

“I don’t think we can wait,” says the former NFL player, 32. “Jessica is too honest about everything, she needs to know. I don’t think she can hold that secret to herself.”

Even if she’s wrong about the baby’s gender, Simpson promises her child will be well dressed.

Photo from PR Photos